• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

Blackhawks vs. Leafs - Nov. 17th, 7:30pm - TSN4

I wasn't commenting on the patience of the fans. Management was impatient. Fans do not necessarily know better. That is not their job. It is management's job.
If management is not patient and trades away a bunch of 1st/2nd rounders for rentals, they'll wind up something like the team we've got - old with few prospects.
A team should be trying to get as much good NHL talent on a roster as they can. There are cap constraints. They need to roll the roster over so they keep the flow of economical, talented youth coming on.

That, right there is the biggest issue. Trading draft picks and good young players away. This has been the largest issue the last 10 years or so since they drafted Matthews.

If we went back through the last 10 years, all the picks and prospects traded away would make for a pretty OK team.
 
Just trying to help those that take it seriously. Have to keep things in perspective. It makes watching a lot less stressful.
I don't think you are wrong on this front. My frustration is with the on ice product. It's not enjoyable watching a team that makes errors but their goaltender gives up 100% of those errors in to goals. It was blatantly apparent right from the start of the game when Bob let that puck trickle through him in the first period that it was going to be yet another abysmal performance.

PP1 works with Marchenko and Tavares. It doesn't work with Roslovic and Tavares. How Hiller doesn't see that is beyond me.

How Hiller didn't look at how McKenna was performing in this game and not see that he deserved more minutes is beyond me.

How Hiller has seen how offensively inept both Joshua and Paul are and yet sits McKenna with both of them is beyond me.

Gavin is incredibly flawed. Every game there are plays where the puck stops moving forward simply because a guy closes out on him and he has no ability to get past a guy on the boards. That's going to take several off-seasons of weight room work to make that change. His defensive instincts are very much at the level of a guy who will be an offensive star who offsets their mediocre defensive game by having the puck more than his opponent. Hiller is putting him into a position to fail by playing him with guys who will never capitalize on any of his offensive abilities.

We need better from everyone.

I'm baffled at how this team is worse than last year. They don't play worse than last year. They do lots of bad things but they have a sieve in net every night and the coach keeps ramming the square peg in the round hole. Bob is honestly worse than Samsonov. At least when Sammy was in net you knew he was giving up goals because he had no clue where the net was. Bob is in position and makes himself so small that he gets beat while being in the right spot to make a save.

The frustrating of watching the team is getting to me. I need a break from that because as you rightfully point out. It's just a game. There are far more important things in life and the Leafs winning/losing doesn't impact any of those real things.

I think it's hitting me in a weird spot right now because I took my son to his first game a few weeks ago. He had the best experience you could possibly have for a first game. He got to fist bump his favourite player (Nylander). He got a puck. He constantly talks about going to that game. And then I'm sitting them steaming at how inept the team is and I'm feeling guilty that I've pushed him toward cheering for this train wreck.
 
I don't think you are wrong on this front. My frustration is with the on ice product. It's not enjoyable watching a team that makes errors but their goaltender gives up 100% of those errors in to goals. It was blatantly apparent right from the start of the game when Bob let that puck trickle through him in the first period that it was going to be yet another abysmal performance.

PP1 works with Marchenko and Tavares. It doesn't work with Roslovic and Tavares. How Hiller doesn't see that is beyond me.

How Hiller didn't look at how McKenna was performing in this game and not see that he deserved more minutes is beyond me.

How Hiller has seen how offensively inept both Joshua and Paul are and yet sits McKenna with both of them is beyond me.

Gavin is incredibly flawed. Every game there are plays where the puck stops moving forward simply because a guy closes out on him and he has no ability to get past a guy on the boards. That's going to take several off-seasons of weight room work to make that change. His defensive instincts are very much at the level of a guy who will be an offensive star who offsets their mediocre defensive game by having the puck more than his opponent. Hiller is putting him into a position to fail by playing him with guys who will never capitalize on any of his offensive abilities.

We need better from everyone.

I'm baffled at how this team is worse than last year. They don't play worse than last year. They do lots of bad things but they have a sieve in net every night and the coach keeps ramming the square peg in the round hole. Bob is honestly worse than Samsonov. At least when Sammy was in net you knew he was giving up goals because he had no clue where the net was. Bob is in position and makes himself so small that he gets beat while being in the right spot to make a save.

The frustrating of watching the team is getting to me. I need a break from that because as you rightfully point out. It's just a game. There are far more important things in life and the Leafs winning/losing doesn't impact any of those real things.

I think it's hitting me in a weird spot right now because I took my son to his first game a few weeks ago. He had the best experience you could possibly have for a first game. He got to fist bump his favourite player (Nylander). He got a puck. He constantly talks about going to that game. And then I'm sitting them steaming at how inept the team is and I'm feeling guilty that I've pushed him toward cheering for this train wreck.
The frustration is real. As an older person who has wanted to see them win a cup since I was a young person, I feel like there has been a lot of wasted years on this team.

I really do think that Leaf fans don't understand the leverage that they have. When things go bad in Montreal or Ottawa, the fans stop going to the games. They voice their frustration with the product on the ice by saying you aren't going to get our time or money until you fix this. The same thing does not happen in Toronto. People still go, they still buy the streaming packages, they still click on every Toronto article. I don't think there is anything wrong with saying "I'm not going to watch until the team gets better". I don't think there is any rule that says that you lose your fandom card because you stop watching a train wreck. This season is obviously a train wreck.

I do believe that Rogers wants to build a winner. I don't think that they don't care. The lack of financial incentive though to fix these problems leads to poor decisions being made at a high level, and the trickle down from those mistakes causes the Leafs to flounder year after year. More money does not equal more innovation.
 
Last edited:
And I do think that not rebuilding was the right move this offseason.

Matthews was coming off back to back down seasons. He would have been a valuable trade asset still but you can sell him as an elite 1st line player instead of just a really good two way player now.

Rielly may have built up some trade value again looking like a more competent player and showing he can still put up points without 1st PP time.

As much as the grunt players are meh acquisitions, Blueger, Duhaime, Paul, Sissons, etc....these are all guys who have real value at the trade deadline.

Tavares was probably never getting traded either way. Nylander is in one hell of a slump/injured right now but ultimately he's still going to have real value.

That value isn't gone by pushing the trades to the deadline or even the offseason.

I still think this team is in a better spot to rebuild today than they were on July 1st.

I also don't think we see the Leafs pivot until much closer to the trade deadline.
 
Holmberg, Engvall, Johnsson, Brown, Leivo, Gunnarsson, Reimer, Stalberg, Komarov, Stralman, Mitchell, Ian White, Wellwood, Ponikarovsky all came after Kaberle and all drafted after RD2. Some had limited time with the Leafs but all played with the big club.
I made a table of all the players you listed:
PlayerDraft PositionGames Played
Pontus Holmberg6th round, 156 OA159
Pierre Engvall7th round, 188 OA226
Connor Brown6th round, 156 OA253
Josh Leivo3rd round, 86 OA57
Carl Gunnarsson7th round, 194 OA304
James Reimer4th round, 99 OA207
Victor Stalberg6th round, 161 OA40
Leo Komarov6th round, 180 OA327
Anton Stralman7th round, 216 OA88
John Mitchell5th round, 158 OA159
Ian White6th round, 191 OA296
Kyle Wellwood5th round, 134 OA189
Alexei Ponikarovsky4th round, 87 OA477

And this is Kaberle:
Tomas Kaberle8th round, 204 OA878

Kaberle last played for the Leafs in 2011. Also some of those players in the list above, were taken during the same time period, or played for the same regime as Tomas Kaberle, like Alexei Ponikarovsky.

I'm not saying you have to hit on a specific number of late round picks, but Kaberle last played for the Leafs in 2011, so in 15 years, they haven't drafted a player outside the the first two rounds that has played more than 400 games for them (I am discarding Alexei Ponikarovsky here because he last played for the Leafs in 2010).

As cw said, it's a myriad of things. Like Connor Brown probably should have been a Leaf for longer, but they had to give him up to get rid of Zaitsev. They didn't resign Pontus Holmberg two years ago, why is that? Is he that much worse than a guy like Colton Scissons? On top of that, their hesitance to give guys like Villeneuve a longer look with big club means that either he isn't worthy of being an NHL player, or the Leafs are afraid to see if he is worthy of being an NHL player. Either reason is bad from a management perspective. I think this is an issue they need to address internally because it affects their roster construction approach.
 
I wasn't commenting on the patience of the fans. Management was impatient. Fans do not necessarily know better. That is not their job. It is management's job.
If management is not patient and trades away a bunch of 1st/2nd rounders for rentals, they'll wind up something like the team we've got - old with few prospects.
A team should be trying to get as much good NHL talent on a roster as they can. There are cap constraints. They need to roll the roster over so they keep the flow of economical, talented youth coming on.
"It requires patience that few - including the fans - seem to have."

It's hard not to read that as partially a shot at the fans.
 
I don't think you are wrong on this front. My frustration is with the on ice product. It's not enjoyable watching a team that makes errors but their goaltender gives up 100% of those errors in to goals. It was blatantly apparent right from the start of the game when Bob let that puck trickle through him in the first period that it was going to be yet another abysmal performance.

....

I think it's hitting me in a weird spot right now because I took my son to his first game a few weeks ago. He had the best experience you could possibly have for a first game. He got to fist bump his favourite player (Nylander). He got a puck. He constantly talks about going to that game. And then I'm sitting them steaming at how inept the team is and I'm feeling guilty that I've pushed him toward cheering for this train wreck.

You reminded me of games I went to as young boy with my father. (years ago, I sent RickC some of the programs from those games) I can't tell you much about the game on the ice. Back then, in the early years for me, the games on TV were in black and white. So going to a game was a little like the Land of Oz - everything was in colour! :) The atmosphere - how loud the crowd was, etc - it was an experience. The important thing was it was an event I got to attend with my Dad. He knew where to go so I got to meet the players. Seeing the players up close is the thing I really remember and that my Dad helped make that happen. Leafs could have been the worst team in the league and I doubt I would feel any differently. That is probably close to how your son will feel about it a few decades later.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YYZ
The frustration is real. As an older person who has wanted to see them win a cup since I was a young person, I feel like there has been a lot of wasted years on this team.

I really do think that Leaf fans don't understand the leverage that they have. When things go bad in Montreal or Ottawa, the fans stop going to the games. They voice their frustration with the product on the ice by saying you aren't going to get our time or money until you fix this. The same thing does not happen in Toronto. People still go, they still buy the streaming packages, they still click on every Toronto article. I don't think there is anything wrong with saying "I'm not going to watch until the team gets better". I don't think there is any rule that says that you lose your fandom card because you stop watching a train wreck. This season is obviously a train wreck.

I do believe that Rogers wants to build a winner. I don't think that they don't care. The lack of financial incentive though to fix these problems leads to poor decisions being made at a high level, and the trickle down from those mistakes causes the Leafs to flounder year after year. More money does not equal more innovation.
I would argue that this came from overspending during the last regime and the knock on effect of cost cutting after so much money was wasted over the last 10yrs. They were averse to hiring another high cost coach - see how long they were paying Babcock and Berube. They were hoping for maybe an outside the box thinker after overspending on Shanahan and Tre for years. They wanted to streamline parts of bloated front offices. But I think they may have learned the wrong lessons from those years. I think spending money on the best front office talent should be a priority, and just because it didn't work out with the Shanny regime doesn't mean you should either leave the role vacant or hire the Temu versions.
 
You reminded me of games I went to as young boy with my father. (years ago, I sent RickC some of the programs from those games) I can't tell you much about the game on the ice. Back then, in the early years for me, the games on TV were in black and white. So going to a game was a little like the Land of Oz - everything was in colour! :) The atmosphere - how loud the crowd was, etc - it was an experience. The important thing was it was an event I got to attend with my Dad. He knew where to go so I got to meet the players. Seeing the players up close is the thing I really remember and that my Dad helped make that happen. Leafs could have been the worst team in the league and I doubt I would feel any differently. That is probably close to how your son will feel about it a few decades later.
Good post. I have a similar experience about my first game at Maple Leaf Gardens. My dad worked with the father of the head trainer. We showed up at the game and got signed Maple Leaf flags from every member of the team. That team had guys like Clark, Damphouse, and Daniel Marios. I think Allen Bester was in net.

They lost to the Islanders 3-2 that night. Still an amazing memory.

At other games I met Kirk Muller, Doug Gilmour, and Felix Potvin, because my Dad and I would go down to the rink early to see the players arrive.

I think there is a difference when you are young, and you haven't lived through that many embarrassing times. As you get older and you start to see this pattern of ineptitude, times like these just get harder.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
3,002
Messages
409,625
Members
817
Latest member
AndyC
Back
Top