• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

Blackhawks vs. Leafs - Nov. 17th, 7:30pm - TSN4

The last time the Leafs went through something like this they missed the playoffs for 9 straight years and 11 of 12. This could be very ugly for a really long time. The reason being that the team will focus on just trying to make the playoffs rather than build a team, and they believe they can solve their problems with money. So buckle up, I don't get the sense this is going to get better anytime soon.

Pshaw. They're already better situated than the last time their window slammed shut. Leafs didn't draft 1OA in 2005. When they pulled the plug, the best U23 player that they had was like Jiří Tlustý.
 
Just trying to help those that take it seriously. Have to keep things in perspective. It makes watching a lot less stressful.
I'm in between
I didn't like what Treliving did - especially his handling of Marner
I haven't embraced what Chayka has done because I thought they should blow it up and not invest $21M in a 38 year old goalie, etc
So they didn't do things I thought they should do.
But regardless, I'm a Leafs fan and I still pull for them.

This season, many, including me, thought they were a bubble team.
So I've been cheering for them to do well and maybe we'd see a round of playoffs.

These last few games, I've found them tougher to take.
They're flirting (or worse) with the season being effectively over in the middle of November - after 23 games.
It is a letdown.
I've been genuinely disappointed in the results.
 

I didn't watch the players. I watched Hiller.
He was "disappointed" too.
He didn't have many answers.
They're in trouble.

I think others noticed: Matthews came out with fire. He made a relentless effort throughout the game - until it got out of reach. Tavares, who does not seem 100%, also has made some good effort in the last two games. And, shock of shocks, William Nylander skated noticeably hard to come back defensively on a play in the early going. So it is sad that they were trying and got blown out by the second worst team in the league.

Their coach doesn't seem to have specific answers/solutions. They're in a precarious place where this could get uglier than it already is ... with no chance of a lottery pick.
 
Pshaw. They're already better situated than the last time their window slammed shut. Leafs didn't draft 1OA in 2005. When they pulled the plug, the best U23 player that they had was like Jiří Tlustý.
Yeah, but you still have to make the right decisions. Having a 1st OA doesn't guarantee success. The Leafs currently have 3 on their roster and look at how bad they are.

If the mandate from up high is "make the playoffs" and each year they make decisions trying to make the playoffs, we've seen what that mandate leads too.

Rumour has it that the reason Chayka got the job is he presented a plan around getting the Leafs into the playoffs. That plan is flawed. What it means is that the Leafs won't do the smart thing like trade Nylander or Matthews. They'll hold on to them until Matthews walks and Nylander has less value than he does today. The problem is the organization has too much money. There are no repercussions for their bad decisions.
 
Rumour has it that the reason Chayka got the job is he presented a plan around getting the Leafs into the playoffs.
Pelley basically said that he wanted his new GM to attempt to return to the playoffs during his press conference after the dismissal of Treliving. It strikes me as beyond a rumour.
I'm sure a number of candidates suggested a rebuild and that probably eliminated them from Pelley's list and helped to keep Chayka on it. Chayka told Pelley what Pelley said he wanted to hear.
 
Pelley basically said that he wanted his new GM to attempt to return to the playoffs during his press conference after the dismissal of Treliving. It strikes me as beyond a rumour.
I'm sure a number of candidates suggested a rebuild and that probably eliminated them from Pelley's list and helped to keep Chayka on it. Chayka told Pelley what Pelley said he wanted to hear.
I wish for once they would hire someone based on what we the fans wanted to hear.
 
I wish for once they would hire someone based on what we the fans wanted to hear.
Looking over the comments on this board, what fans want is all over the place.

There was nothing wrong with the Shanaplan at the outset. To me, the problems began when the MLSE board tried to short circuit it - pressuring Dubas to accelerate getting to the promised land via mortgages of their future. It requires patience that few - including the fans - seem to have.
 
McKenna did some nice things...Hiller rewards him with 3:20 in TOI

He is a very stupid coach

Tavares has been dog shit since coming back in the lineup and force feeding him on PP1 has been a problem

I do wonder if this approach with McKenna's usage is coming from above.
 
Looking over the comments on this board, what fans want is all over the place.

There was nothing wrong with the Shanaplan at the outset. To me, the problems began when the MLSE board tried to short circuit it - pressuring Dubas to accelerate getting to the promised land via mortgages of their future. It requires patience that few - including the fans - seem to have.
Okay, that's fair. What I want is for someone to figure out why the Leafs consistently shoot themselves in the foot, and fix the reasons for that. I just want them to start there.

Has any other team in the League given up as many prime first round picks as the Leafs have in deals? Off the top of my head there is Niedermayer, Seguin, Hamilton, and now potentially Dupont.

And on top of that, not only do they give up primes first round picks, they also can't seem to stomach developing a player outside the first 2 rounds. When is the last time the Leafs developed a player that could play in the NHL consistently that they picked past round 2 that they kept? Kaberle is the only one I can think of.

For the last 60 years hey have been, and continue to be a poorly run franchise. And we keep footing the bill.
 
....
And on top of that, not only do they give up primes first round picks, they also can't seem to stomach developing a player outside the first 2 rounds. When is the last time the Leafs developed a player that could play in the NHL consistently that they picked past round 2 that they kept? Kaberle is the only one I can think of.
Only about 1.5% of drafted NHLers finish their career with the team that drafted them
 
Okay, that's fair. What I want is for someone to figure out why the Leafs consistently shoot themselves in the foot, and fix the reasons for that. I just want them to start there.

Has any other team in the League given up as many prime first round picks as the Leafs have in deals? Off the top of my head there is Niedermayer, Seguin, Hamilton, and now potentially Dupont.

And on top of that, not only do they give up primes first round picks, they also can't seem to stomach developing a player outside the first 2 rounds. When is the last time the Leafs developed a player that could play in the NHL consistently that they picked past round 2 that they kept? Kaberle is the only one I can think of.

For the last 60 years hey have been, and continue to be a poorly run franchise. And we keep footing the bill.
At least with Ballard we knew what he was, this is entirely different, after he passed we were promised things would be different, but here we are still making bad decisions, it's truly mind numbing.
 
Only about 1.5% of drafted NHLers finish their career with the team that drafted them
Okay, so you are taking the extreme of my argument there. Even Kaberle didn't finish his career with the Leafs. We need more than the Holmbergs and Engvalls where they play a couple of years and then either sign somewhere else or are trade fodder is all I am saying. This team does not want to give any player drafted outside the top 2 rounds a chance. So either they don't trust that that type of player can handle it, or they really suck at drafting outside the first 2 rounds
 
And on top of that, not only do they give up primes first round picks, they also can't seem to stomach developing a player outside the first 2 rounds. When is the last time the Leafs developed a player that could play in the NHL consistently that they picked past round 2 that they kept? Kaberle is the only one I can think of.
Holmberg, Engvall, Johnsson, Brown, Leivo, Gunnarsson, Reimer, Stalberg, Komarov, Stralman, Mitchell, Ian White, Wellwood, Ponikarovsky all came after Kaberle and all drafted after RD2. Some had limited time with the Leafs but all played with the big club.
 
Okay, so you are taking the extreme of my argument there. Even Kaberle didn't finish his career with the Leafs. We need more than the Holmbergs and Engvalls where they play a couple of years and then either sign somewhere else or are trade fodder is all I am saying. This team does not want to give any player drafted outside the top 2 rounds a chance. So either they don't trust that that type of player can handle it, or they really suck at drafting outside the first 2 rounds
There are a whole bunch of reasons for this.
Some of it is arguably mismanagement and lack of patience, etc
Some poor drafting, etc
I have not got time to go through all of it.
I'll agree that there were better paths for them to take - they made mistakes - some of them big.
 

Members online

Forum statistics

Threads
3,002
Messages
409,611
Members
817
Latest member
AndyC
Back
Top