• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

Search results

  1. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    If I'm looking at this from your perspective, I would be suspicious whether JVR is very damaged goods not just injury-prone. On Schenn, I'm not so sure that he doesn't carry some chronic injuries himself. I know he injured his knee in his rookie season. My memory is that Schenn was more mobile...
  2. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    Oops, I'm still keeping the names straight. I thought I was playing Potvin29's game not the hockey clich? game. ;)
  3. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    Is there empirical proof that defensemen take longer to develop than forwards? I think it's just easier to shelter a young forward in an NHL lineup than a young defenseman just due to numbers. In many ways, playing forward is a more varied task.
  4. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    Thanks for the link to the site. Working those numbers is fun. I think I take back accepting Luke Schenn as playing sheltered minutes based on the numbers I saw and worked with. Although he certainly wasn't put in a position to fail either as THN claimed. I calculated what I'd call...
  5. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    At 50.7%, I'd take that as definite evidence of sheltering a defender especially considering what inept point man he is. Of course when you have Phaneuf, Schenn and Komisarek dressed as right side defenders on any given night, Schenn is going to be the second choice for even strength offensive...
  6. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    I'm confused now. Did Schenn start a majority of shifts after a whistle in the offensive or defensive zone during the 2011/12 season? Only in the offensive zone is it sheltering a defender as far as I'm concerned. Otherwise in the defensive zone it's supposedly just playing to the player's...
  7. L

    Qualifying Offers Thread

    Fraser did play well in the AHL playoffs but there are mobility issues for the NHL. I don't think Mueller is energetic enough to make a go of it in the NHL, I'm alright with letting him walk. I'd consider qualifying Gysbers too. He's no worse than Holzer and only about 8 months older. I...
  8. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    I think you should ask yourself why my position upsets you so much that you need to get confrontational over it, especially the thought that I might win a bet over it. I thought we were supposed to be having fun here.
  9. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    Talk about taking something completely out of context. Yikes.
  10. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    Really, Burke has only had one real opportunity to do this with Kadri who was clearly too slight and a defensive liability at 18, 19. Otherwise he traded away his other possibilities for Phil Kessel. I'll also point out that he did allow Jerry D'Amigo to play in the AHL at 19 and put Matt...
  11. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    Sure. Loser donates $25 to TMLFans.ca. If Morgan Rielly plays 1 game or more for the Toronto Maple Leafs during the 2012-13 regular season excepting games after the WHL season has ended, you donate $25 to www.tmlfans.ca (I'm assuming you're not an owner of the site). If Morgan Rielly is...
  12. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    Reason #1: Last year of Burke's contract. Adding a talented 18 year old defenseman could be just that piece of optimism that gets Burke an extension from the penny pinchers at Rogers and Bell. Reason #2: Burke stated that the Leafs had him rated no. 1 in this draft. If I'd ever heard a tee-up...
  13. L

    Do you believe Burke would draft Rielly first overall?

    I don't care whether it's true or not. Burke has said lots of stuff for public consumption. What I'm more concerned about is that it's a virtual lock that Burke will want this guy in the team's lineup in the fall.
  14. L

    Did the Leafs Ruin Schenn's Development?

    No but there was probably a better path. Would another year in juniors have made him a better skater? Or given him better skills? Or given him better hockey sense? I'm not sure. Instinctively I sort of believe otherwise. I think that I got more out of playing better opposition when I played at...
  15. L

    Line-up changes - Part II

    About the bottom 6 I think the top 6 is more competitive than last season's bottom 6. Steckel sucks at everything apart from winning faceoffs. However Carlyle seemed to believe in him. I don't think it's a coincidence that Steckel's ice time went up during the team's swan dive. In theory, a big...
  16. L

    Luke Schenn Traded to Flyers for JVR!!!

    The problem with Schenn's shot is that he takes an eternity to release it. He lacks the hands and agility to get what is actually a fairly hard shot off against professional opponents. That has not improved in his 4 years in the NHL.
  17. L

    Luke Schenn Traded to Flyers for JVR!!!

    It's amazing how much better Luke Schenn has become within the media since this trade was announced. I actually think this is a much less significant deal than it first appears. Schenn has been stuck in development limbo as a robotic, yet rugged defender who's adept at firing wrist shots in...
  18. L

    2012 NHL Entry Draft

    Brown was the leading scorer on perhaps the worst OHL team since Don Cherry thought he knew how to run a junior team. He was an astonishing -72 this season. The Leafs probably saw a lot of him while checking on McKegg and Olden. Ryan Rupert has a twin brother Matt playing with him on the...
  19. L

    2012 NHL Entry Draft

    How can you argue with a straight face that the Leafs should have chosen with the 5th pick in the draft a player who at best went 11th? If you want to argue that the Leafs picked the wrong defenseman, maybe I could take it seriously.
Back
Top