• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick at: couchmanrick@gmail.com

Search results

  1. P

    2019 Toronto Maple Leafs Offseason Discussion

    Just watched Coaches Corner. Commenting on the hit that put Tavares on his ass, Don Cherry stated Leafs aren't tough enough for the playoffs and won't win the SC. I won't be as quick as Grapes to make a conclusion so early in the season but I agree Leafs aren't showing the toughness needed to...
  2. P

    2019 Toronto Maple Leafs Offseason Discussion

    One observation this preseason. A rookie takes a run at Matthews, elbow up and then sticks a knee out, and nobody does anything.
  3. P

    Leafs to announce captain

    Imo, the best player, or even the 'franchise' player, isn't necessarily always the best choice for captain. The last 4 Stanley Cups this team won were not captained by the best player - that dynasty was captained by the best leader, one George Armstrong. I think Leafs will go with the trend...
  4. P

    2019 Toronto Maple Leafs Offseason Discussion

    I'm coming in late in this discussion so please bear with me. Imo, On their own, Oz's statements don't mean much but when you consider the Zaitsev comments and request for a trade; Matthews' statement regarding Kapanen; Leafs treatment of Sparks last year; Dubas failure to sign Nylander to...
  5. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    I would have agreed with you ten years ago. But if it's true that "...with good ownership there's no real impediment to success....." then Leafs owners the last 9 seasons can't be good. What's so bad about the current owners. Where do they come short as far as ownership goes? My proposal is...
  6. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    My apology. I missed the reference to Occam's Razor. But does your reference apply as you intended? My proposal makes matters less complicated. Instead of discussing poor scouting, poor drafting, poor coaching, no leadership, lazy players, incompetence, the media, impatient fans, etc, etc...
  7. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    No, coming in second place isn't success but Leafs haven't even made it that far while other teams have. What criteria do you think is appropriate? What is success -  Winning %? Stanley cups? Personal player achievements? Playoff series won? Can you name others? Lets use them all. What you will...
  8. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    Buffalo and Vancouver both made it to the final twice. Two St. Louis Blues won the Norris. I'd bet that both Buffalo and St.Louis have a better winning % in the last 45+ years and Vancouver is probably closer to Leafs horrible record. Are there any other teams you wish to compare Leafs dismal...
  9. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    You think Fletcher and Quinn were patient? Quite the opposite. Stavros wasn't any different than any of the other owners. If that era was 'successful' it was because those two guys were able to thumb their noses at the owners. Fletcher's team was finally dismantled because of pressure from...
  10. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    You keep mentioning success the team has experienced. What success? That's the problem. You don't see the big picture. In the last 45+ years I'll bet Leafs performance is in the bottom 33% of the teams that were around in 1971. During that time no leaf has won a major trophy and only two...
  11. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    That's pretty much what my argument is.....the problems go beyond players coaches and managers....the problems are at the upper levels of management. But blaming it on 'ownership' has its problems too, because ownership changed many times over the last 45+ years...and if anything Leaf...
  12. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    If the reasons given are vague its because I don't work in the upper offices of MLSE to fully understand the problems. I have enough experience to offer suggestions, but these can never be verified so why bother? We're just Leaf fans exchanging thoughts for fun. My argument is easy to...
  13. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    You seem like the kind of guy who likes to have the last word. You also don't read and understand my posts. I never talked of sea monsters. Cultural issues are very real and anybody in industry knows what I mean. Do yourself a favor. Check-out the Leafs winning percentage since '67. Where do...
  14. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    And that's where you and I differ. Why is Montreal a ridiculous benchmark? Isn't that where we'd like to be? Would you be happy with second place? I've been around a long time my friend and witnessed all the eras I write about. I remember a time when we were the best. Can you say the same...
  15. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    A patient rebuild started in 1969 with the promotion of Dorey, Ley, Pelyk, Quinn and a year later, with McKenny and Glennie. The rebuild continued in the 70's with the addition of Sittler, Kehoe, Thompson, ferguson, Harrison, Dupere.......that group wouldn't have made the play-offs if Chicago...
  16. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    So you believe Iafrate fulfilled his promise in Toronto?
  17. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    You're missing the big picture. The Burns and Quinn eras were successful. Modestly successful. Take the most successful Leaf seasons since '67 (5 seasons in which Leafs reached the final 4)  and place them alongside Montreal's achievements during that time and the most successful Leaf seasons...
  18. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    You're not being an ass at all....you helped me prove my point. I look at the  list and I think....That's It? Is that all the center of the hockey universe was capable of producing? No Norris trophy, no Art Ross or Hart trophy winners in 50 years? Not even a single Calder winner? Not one Leaf...
  19. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    Iafrate was a great prospect - Norris trophy material - but that never happened. In Toronto he wasn't great.... he under performed and was part of some of the worst Leafs' teams in the history of the organization. He's a great example of how this team has mishandled great talent.
  20. P

    2015 NHL Entry Draft

    Of course you need both, but you're missing the point. Drafting and development are separate activities. For example, Thommie Bergman scouted Steen and recommended him to management. With this advice Leafs drafted. At that point Bergman hands over the rest of Steen's career to others. Bergman...
Back
Top